• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Comic Book Herald

A Comic Book Reading Order Guide For Beginners & Fans

  • Reading Orders
    • Marvel
    • My Marvelous Year
    • DC Comics
    • All Comic Book Publishers
    • Most Recent
  • Beginner Guides
    • Beginner’s Guide To Comics In 2025
    • Marvel 2025: Where to Start?
    • DC 2025: Where to Start?
    • Best of Lists
    • Tablets for Comics
    • Guides for Digital Readers
  • Reviews
    • Marvel Comics
    • DC Comics
    • Comic Book Movies
    • Comic Book TV
    • Video Games
  • Podcasts & Video
    • My Marvelous Year
    • Best Comics Ever (CBH)
    • CBH on Youtube!
  • About Me
    • My Favorite Comics of All Time
    • Columns
    • CBH Email Newsletter
  • Support Comic Book Herald
    • Ways to support
You are here: Home / Featured / Crossover #1 Advance Review!

Crossover #1 Advance Review!

October 26, 2020 by Sean Dillon Leave a Comment

The problem with writing about Crossover #1 is that the most interesting aspect of the book occurs on its final page. It’s a combination of text and image that retroactively changes how the issue is read. The implications of the page would require thousands of words unpacking (among other things) why Mark Waid is editing this book, the rise of conservatism within superhero comics since 1986, the tendency to distort ideas into mere buzzwords, one of the many reasons why I no longer have any faith in humanity, a truly wretched and distasteful Tori Amos analogy about the difference between Donny Cates and Mark Millar, why the Captain Marvel cameo was recolored despite him being a public domain character, the acronym DSHKBAWKA, and the time no one noticed Superboy gruesomely (if accidentally) killing a cat.

And this would all make for a pretty damn good review if not for the ethics of explicitly talking about the final page in a review not only predating the comic being released, but also one provided by the publisher of said comic (Ed: Thanks, Image!). It can be implied, sketched around, but it cannot yet be stated. As such, the task at hand must be focused squarely on what is known to the public. What can be talked about. And, in fairness, there are things to talk about beyond that final page.

A close up of a sign Description automatically generated

The main conceit of Crossover #1 is imagining a world where nerds are an actual oppressed group of people. To say that this idea is in questionable taste would be an understatement. Putting aside the implications of using Westboro Baptist Church rhetoric on a demographic framed within the comic as predominately white men, the history of nerd culture is, shall we say, uncomfortable to say the least. Among the many ugly actions of nerd culture, you have the tendency for con-goers to sexually harass booth babes, the normalization of abuse within fandom circles such that death threats are considered part of fandom drama, and a general history of male fans kicking women out of spaces they forged and remaking it in their own image.

But the most notable instance of fandom cruelty is that of #gamergate. #gamergate was a harassment campaign that began in 2014 wherein an ex-boyfriend wrote a salacious op-ed about Zoë Quinn wherein he argued that she was sleeping around with several critics in order to get a better review score on her game, Depression Quest. This spiraled, intentionally and not, into a full blown right wing terrorist cell wherein several women were harassed, threatened with death via explosion, and actively attacked for the crime of being female in a nerd space. It was fueled by, among a number of fans, the Right-Wing news website Breitbart and one of its writers, Milo Yiannopoulos. While #gamergate’s main goal of getting rid of the women infecting nerd spaces ultimately failed miserably, it did act as a lead balloon to see who to contact when a right wing presidential candidate needed to be elected into office. The success of that is very painful.

So making a comic about nerds being oppressed like minorities in a post #gamergate era is questionable to say the least. Equally troublesome is Crossover’s uncritical appropriation of the works of Fredric Wertham and his study Seduction of the Innocent. For those unaware, Wertham was a psychologist whose aforementioned study (along with other, less famous arguments against the comic book medium) led the way to the Comics Code of America and, subsequently, a rise in conservative politics in the Superhero genre that would lead creators like Eric Kripke and Alan Moore to argue that the whole genre is inherently fascist. While his study did have some good points about body image, it’s ultimately let down by, at best, shoddy research, a belief in reproductive futurism, and homophobia. His disdain for the medium, and the superhero aspect of it in particular, is palpable.

 

Support For Comic Book Herald:

Comic Book Herald is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a qualifying affiliate commission.

Comic Book Herald’s reading orders and guides are also made possible by My Marvelous Year club support on Patreon, and generous reader donations.

Any size contribution will help keep CBH alive and full of new comics guides and content. Support CBH’s My Marvelous Year on Patreon for exclusive rewards, or Donate here! Thank you for reading!

To be fair to Crossover #1, its invocation of Wertham has a degree of tongue in cheek. Opening the issue by contrasting his words with a simplified take on the superhero genre by Todd McFarlane is an obvious gag, but one that could theoretically work. And the side character Otto wearing a ‘Wertham was Right’ T-Shirt, while questionable in terms of taste, is again a solid gag. But there’s a degree to which it’s not doing enough of a critique of Wertham’s work in its invocation, to say nothing of the anxiety nerd culture has for Wertham even decades after his death. As if not mentioning or invoking him in every single piece of comics about comics about comics about comics will cause him to come back from the dead and kill the industry.

A picture containing photo, covered, many, different Description automatically generated

It should be noted that all of what I’ve just written is only a part of the core conceit of Crossover. The full conceit asks the question: “What if an event comic on a multiversal scale actually invaded our Earth?” And there are certainly a lot of fun things you could do with that premise from having fictional characters from other Image Comics (or what have you) appear, or have the fictional characters be an oppressed race due to the violence and mass slaughter the crisis has brought upon the world. And, to the book’s credit, it does some of those things.

The problem is that it applies them clunkily. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the narration that funnels throughout the book. With previous efforts at narration, Cates has shown a great degree of strength, able to create a mythic quality to the lives of mundane characters and suck you in. With Crossover #1, however, the narration feels obtrusive. Like it’s trying way too hard to be about something (be it the nature of reality via a CliffsNotes Supergods, hyping up the story, or introducing us to people).

Nowhere is this more apparent than in the final portion of the narration in the issue, wherein it hastily declares this to be a love story between two characters. One of whom the issue actually focuses on while the other is essentially given filler dialogue that tells us nothing about him.

Now the set up to an unlikely romance can work. Consider Ales Kot and Tradd Moore’s The New World, wherein we are introduced to two characters who barely interact, but we are given so much detail. It should be noted that that the first issue of The New World was a double length issue, and thus arguably a bad comparison. (Though I would note that a lot of Crossover #1’s challenges could have been resolved if the issue was released as a double sized issue.)

As such, let’s instead compare it to a recently released #1: Rorschach by Tom King and Jorge Fornés. Much like Crossover’s first issue, Rorschach is a rather slight comic with a somewhat problematic premise (in Rorschach’s case, a murder mystery following up on the acclaimed graphic novel that questionably, if not tastelessly, involves the real life tragedy of Otto Binder) that’s less interested in introducing characters and more in setting up the plot and some of the thematic interests. Where they differ is in execution. In Rorschach, there is no narration beyond character narration. The details are largely presented to us via Fornés art and coloring by Dave Stewart.

Conversely, Crossover more often than not has narration explain what’s going on rather than allow the art to speak for itself. Which is a shame since Geoff Shaw and Dee Cunniffe are doing tremendous work with the material. Shaw is one of those artists you would think couldn’t do larger than life sci-fi material, let alone superheroes, yet routinely shows the contrast between the mundane and the bizarre. Cunniffe, meanwhile, is capable of depicting the contrast between the real world and the comic book characters infecting it with such a masterful touch that it’s a real shame narration has to tell what we clearly see.

And John J. Hill’s lettering work, while not the star of the book the way a Bidikar or an Otsmane-Elhaou can be, is nevertheless fantastic. To be completely fair, there are some moments of spark with the idea as presented within the context of the single issue when Cates gets out of his own way. For example, the implication that cop comics would be a leading replacement for the superhero genre speaks volumes about an understanding of the material history of the Comics Code, moreso than any billboard declaring “God Hates Masks” or narration pontificating over the nature of Superheroes when you just want to enjoy your Hot Wings in peace.

Ultimately though, the book is probably Cates’ weakest number one I’ve read; a story that, much like Rorschach #1, fails to actually sell its premise well while not actively a bad comic. It’s, at worst, meh and, at best, something that works better in a trade. But where Rorschach #1 is let down by its structure befitting the first chapter of a graphic novel instead of a single issue, Crossover #1 is too enamored with its own premise to do anything except chew our ear off about how great superhero comics and superhero fans are. And the case it makes, ultimately, is a bit weak.

And then there’s that final page where…

A close up of text on a black background Description automatically generated

Filed Under: Featured, Reviews Tagged With: donny cates

Heroically Support Comic Book Herald!

If you like Comic Book Herald, and are able to donate, any small contribution will help keep CBH alive and full of new comics guides and content. Donate here! Or, support CBH on Patreon for exclusive rewards! Thank you for reading!

Become a Patron!

CBH Newsletter!

About Sean Dillon

Sean Dillon is a writer and editor for many outlets, including PanelxPanel, Neotext, and Arcbeatle Press. He is the author of the book One Must Imagine Scott Free Happy, a book length analysis of Tom King and Mitch Gerads' Mister Miracle. They are often found puttering about on twitter @deathchrist2000 or on his personal blog thekinginredandblue.blogspot.com

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

The My Marvelous Year Podcast!

Apple PodcastsRSS

CBH Newsletter!

My Marvelous Year Podcast and Reading Club 1

Recent Posts

  • Extra Issues – Lucifer Pt. 2 (2000) May 8, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 9: Thor: The Mighty Avenger, Bucky on Trial, & Invincible Iron Man May 5, 2025
  • My Favorite Graphic Novels of April 2025 May 1, 2025
  • 2010 Variant Cover D: Dave Interviewed Donny Cates & Chris Claremont! And Daredevil: Born Again Review! April 27, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 8: Daredevil: Shadowland April 21, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 7: Wolverine, Second Coming, & Uncanny X-Force April 14, 2025
  • Extra Issues – Lucifer Pt. 1 (2000) April 7, 2025
  • 2010 Variant Cover C: Marvel Rivals Resurrects the X-Men’s Krakoa, Trivia & Jiggle Physics! April 7, 2025
  • My Favorite Graphic Novels of March 2025 April 7, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 6: Hickman’s Fantastic Four: Three March 31, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 5: Realm of Kings & Thanos Imperative March 24, 2025
  • 2010 Variant Cover B: Daredevil Born Again (Again) TV Series Review! March 17, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 4: Amazing Spider-Man: Big Time & Dave’s Favorite Black Widow Story March 10, 2025
  • My Favorite Graphic Novels of February 2025 March 4, 2025
  • 2010 Pt. 3: Jonathan Hickman’s S.H.I.E.L.D. & Secret Warriors March 3, 2025

Popular Articles

DC Rebirth Guide

Batman Reading Order

DC New 52 Reading Order

Marvel Ultimate Universe Guide

Civil War Reading Order

Marvel Cosmic Reading Order

The Best Comics of All Time!

Deadpool Reading Order

Justice League Reading Order

Complete Thanos Reading Order

X-Men Reading Guide (Modern Era)

Age of Apocalypse Reading Order

Modern Marvel Universe in 25 Trades

Best Tablet For Digital Comics

Is Marvel Unlimited Worth It?

Footer

New to Comic Book Herald?

Hey there - my name's Dave and this is my comic book blog. It's my way of sharing my borderline obsessive addiction to the comic book medium, and I hope you like some of what's going on here.

Most people that come here are looking for my (WIP) Marvel reading order guide. You can probably also get a sense if CBH is for you by taking a look at some of my columns.

If you like what you see, let's connect on Facebook or Twitter. Or, leave a comment on the blog here, I'm always looking for new awesome people in the comic book community.

More on Comic Book Herald

  • Home
  • About
  • Support CBH
  • My Marvelous Year
  • Join!
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service

Recent Posts

  • Extra Issues – Lucifer Pt. 2 (2000)
  • 2010 Pt. 9: Thor: The Mighty Avenger, Bucky on Trial, & Invincible Iron Man
  • My Favorite Graphic Novels of April 2025
  • 2010 Variant Cover D: Dave Interviewed Donny Cates & Chris Claremont! And Daredevil: Born Again Review!
  • 2010 Pt. 8: Daredevil: Shadowland

Copyright © 2025 · Metro Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in